Shiny object syndrome: the danger of moving too fast

Shiny object syndrome is costing businesses more than ever. AI makes every new project easy to start, so someone has to decide what's actually worth doing.

Shiny object syndrome: the danger of moving too fast

AI has given most businesses a bad case of shiny object syndrome. Everyone wants to know how fast they can launch the next thing, automate it and get it live.

It's the wrong question. It's not how fast we can do something. It's whether we should be doing it in the first place.

The FOMO is real

The world is changing faster every month, and you can feel it. Every week there's a new AI tool, a new platform and a new "you're already behind" post on LinkedIn. Watch enough of it and you start to believe everyone else has worked something out that you haven't.

That feeling is FOMO, and right now it's making a lot of business decisions. Grant Thornton surveyed 950 business leaders in early 2026 and found that competitors' moves were the biggest outside pressure pushing them into AI. In their words, many are "motivated by the fear of falling behind rather than a clear, practical view of where AI creates value".

Call it AI FOMO. It isn't a strategy. But it's very good at feeling like one.

What shiny object syndrome looks like in a business

Shiny object syndrome is chasing whatever's new and exciting before the last thing is finished.

There's a scene in The Matrix where Morpheus walks Neo through a busy street, explaining something that matters. Neo's eyes follow a woman in a red dress. Morpheus asks if he was listening or looking at her. When Neo looks again, she's an agent pointing a gun at him. She was put there to distract him.

In a business, the woman in the red dress rarely looks like a distraction. She looks like progress. A chatbot on the website. A TikTok shop. A podcast. A new CRM because someone saw a good demo. Each one sounds sensible in the meeting where it comes up. Each one gets a bit of time, a bit of budget and a bit of someone's attention.

Six months later you've got six half-finished things, a team that's flat out, and the numbers that matter haven't moved.

AI has made starting things free

This is where it's got worse. AI has made starting a project almost free. You can have a website mock-up, a marketing plan, an app prototype and a month of social posts by lunchtime.

Starting was always the easy part. Now it's effortless. Finishing, and choosing what's worth finishing, hasn't got any easier.

So businesses are running more projects than ever, and a lot of them are going nowhere. WRITER surveyed 1,200 executives and 1,200 employees for its 2026 report. 55% described AI use at their company as a "chaotic free-for-all". 79% said AI applications were being built in silos. And 75% of executives admitted their AI strategy was "more for show" than real guidance.

MIT's NANDA initiative found much the same in 2025. According to its report, only about 5% of company AI pilots achieve rapid revenue growth. The rest mostly stall, "delivering little to no measurable impact on P&L".

That's busy work at scale. Lots of activity. Very little progress.

Busy work isn't progress

Here's the simplest way I can put it. Every project you run pulls the business in a direction. If they all pull roughly the same way, you move. If they pull six different ways, you can work flat out and end up more or less where you started.

Nobody deciding6 projects
More enquiries123456
  1. 1Chatbot on the website
  2. 2TikTok shop
  3. 3Switch to a new CRM
  4. 4Start a podcast
  5. 5Rebrand
  6. 6Google Ads
Effort that reaches the goal15%
Someone deciding3 projects
More enquiries123
  1. 1Reply to every enquiry within five minutes
  2. 2Follow up every quote
  3. 3Ask every happy customer for a review
Effort that reaches the goal98%
Each arrow is a project, and each gets the same share of the team's time. The green arrow is where all that effort actually takes you. (Illustrative.)

Both teams are busy all day. In the first, the projects mostly cancel each other out, and only about 15% of the effort ends up pointing at the goal. In the second, nearly all of it does. Same hours, same people, very different result.

Peter Drucker put it better than anyone, back in 1963: "There is surely nothing quite so useless as doing with great efficiency what should not be done at all."

That's the difference between efficiency and effectiveness. AI makes you efficient. It can't tell you what's worth doing.

Somebody has to decide

This is the bit most businesses are missing. Not more tools and not more ideas. A coordinator. An orchestrator. Someone whose job is to look at every new idea and ask one question before any time gets spent on it: does this move us towards the goal?

Most ideas should get "not now". Not because they're bad, but because they aren't the most important thing.

Every idea, one question
GoalMore enquiries this quarter

Doing it3

  • Reply to every enquiry within five minutesSlow replies are losing us enquiries today.
  • Fix the contact form on phonesMost visitors are on a phone.
  • Ask happy customers for Google reviewsPeople check reviews before they get in touch.

Not now4

  • Launch a TikTok shopWe don't sell online. It won't bring enquiries.
  • Switch to a new CRMThe current one works. Use it properly first.
  • Start a podcastMonths of work before it brings a single enquiry.
  • Daily AI-written blog postsMore content isn't more enquiries.
An orchestrator's real job: most good ideas get "not now". (Illustrative.)

In a small business, the orchestrator is usually the owner. The trouble is, the owner is often the one bringing the shiny objects in. It's hard to guard the door and walk through it at the same time.

Whoever does it, the job looks like this:

  • One goal at a time, written down and agreed. More enquiries, more repeat orders, fewer hours lost to admin.
  • Every project earns its place against that goal before it starts, not after.
  • Finish things before starting new ones. A half-built chatbot isn't a chatbot.
  • Stop what isn't working, quickly and without guilt.

AI keeps making the next shiny thing cheaper to start, so this matters more every month. It's the same reason AI is making so many people busier, not freer.

How we work with clients

This is a big part of what we do at LeadDigital. Before we build anything, whether that's an AI agent, a CRM, a website or a campaign, we start with what the business is actually trying to achieve and work back from there.

Then we act as the coordinator across all of it, so the agent, the CRM, the website and the marketing pull in the same direction instead of competing for the same budget and attention. It's the same thinking behind asking how many advertising channels you can really afford, and why I'd rather you stopped automating everything than automated the wrong things well.

Sometimes it means telling a client not to build something. That's often the most valuable thing we do.

Speed only helps once you know where you're going.

James Ketchell avatar
WRITTEN BY

James Ketchell

Related Posts